May 27 (Bloomberg) -- Curves are in, in more ways
than one.
Fashion designers are being forced to consider
women's preferences for a more ample bust, be it
naturally endowed or augmented.
In financial markets, curves are in as well; just
not in the sense of in vogue. The yield curve, or
the pictorial representation of the yields on
Treasury securities across the maturity spectrum,
has come in, or narrowed, to the point that it's
creating a source of consternation for analysts
and investors.
The spread between the overnight federal funds
rate and the 10-year Treasury note rate stands at
112 basis points, down from a peak of 387 basis
points in June 2004, when the funds rate was still
at 1 percent.
The current positive spread is not contractionary;
it's less stimulative than it was a year ago. With
every indication that the Fed plans to proceed
with its agenda of rate increases and every sign
that long rates aren't going to budge in response
(at least not higher), it's possible the curve
could invert before too long.
An inverted yield curve, with short rates higher
than long rates, is typically a harbinger of
recession. Historically, the central bank raises
short-term rates aggressively to constrain
inflation, crimping growth in the process.
This Time Is Different?
Not this time. Reported inflation is tame, and the
Federal Reserve's mission is to normalize short-
term rates so as not to over-stimulate the
economy. With one eye on the recent acceleration
in various measures of inflation, Fed officials
aren't contemplating implementing a contractionary
monetary policy.
So what are we to make of the dramatic flattening
of the yield curve? What is the message?
The yield curve is a simple construct that's
widely misunderstood. Economists invoke it when it
supports their forecast and dismiss it when it
doesn't.
In the past few weeks, I've read or heard the
following comments about the flattening yield
curve:
A flatter yield curve means the Fed will have to
raise short- term rates more;
A flat yield curve usually occurs when short and
long rates are higher. Rates are low now, so the
flatter curve doesn't matter;
A flat/inverted yield curve doesn't mean what it
used to mean.
Inspiration
Such statements inspired me to craft a primer on
the yield curve. For the purposes of this
discussion, the yield curve will connote the
spread between the overnight federal funds rate
and 10-year Treasury note yield.
1. What's so special about two yields among
thousands? What imbues them with such power and
omniscience?
What's special is the information provided by the
interaction between the two rates: one set by the
central bank, the other by the market. While long
rates are influenced by short rates -- the current
short rate and its expected trajectory -- they're
also affected by real activity and inflation
expectations, not to mention a myriad of political
and psychological considerations. The long rate is
a window into the stance of policy.
2. My windows need washing. What do you mean by
the interaction between them?
Consider a world where there is no central bank.
When the demand for credit increases, the price of
credit, or interest rate, will rise.
We have a central bank, as do most countries. Most
of them use an overnight or other short-term rate
as a policy tool. The monetary authority provides
whatever reserves the banking system demands to
achieve its target rate.
If the central bank is holding the short rate
steady, and market rates are rising, it's a pretty
good indication that the overnight rate is too
low.
Why? Because that rate would be rising too were it
not for the Fed's injection of reserves. In other
words, the demand for credit is rising faster than
the Fed can supply it.
3. Who figured this stuff out?
The theory behind the yield curve's role in
anticipating economic growth and inflation can be
traced back to the late Swedish economist Knut
Wicksell (1851-1926). Wicksell argued that when
the rate at which banks lend is below the rate of
return on capital, which he called the natural
rate of interest, prices would rise. When the bank
rate exceeds the natural rate, prices would fall.
4. How do I know what the natural rate of interest
is?
You don't. It's unobservable. Which is why the
interaction between the two rates provides more
information than the absolute level of both rates.
Think of the long rate as a check on the central
bank. If policy is too easy or too tight, it will
send up a flare.
5. Now I'm really confused. How can falling long
rates be a negative? Isn't there more incentive to
borrow at 5 percent than 6 percent?
Yes. And that's one part of the story. If you only
looked at the level of long-term rates, the Great
Depression should have been the Great Boom, and
Japan's lost decade should have been Paradise
Regained.
In both cases, low long-term rates were a symptom
of weak economic growth, not a cause of stronger
growth in the future.
During the Great Depression, the Fed let the money
supply contract by one-third. There was no demand
for credit even at a rock-bottom price.
6. Low mortgage rates have created a boom in
housing. How can you say a flatter yield curve is
less stimulative? Don't you read the papers?
Yes, I read them. Ceteris paribus, declining
mortgage rates make home ownership more
affordable. In the micro world of housing, credit
demand is strong.
For the U.S. economy overall, there are more
lenders (savers) at any given rate than there were
before. Whether it's Asian central banks or
private investors wanting a risk-free investment,
more people are choosing to save in dollars, which
is pushing down long-term rates.
7. So how can that be bad?
It's bad -- or at this point, less good -- because
there's less incentive for commercial banks to
increase the money supply. The steeper the yield
curve, the more incentive there is to borrow from
the Fed at the overnight rate and lend money to
the private sector or Uncle Sam (buy Treasuries)
at a higher rate.
It's no surprise that money supply growth has
slowed in response to a flatter yield curve. The
money supply has gone out of fashion, but I'm an
old codger.
8. You mean there's more to the yield curve than
the difference between two points?
Yes. But if you can grasp the fundamentals, you'll
be way ahead of the curve -- I mean, ahead of most
investment professionals.